userType: external

gitBranch: claude/intelligent-yalow

slug: swift-imagining-prism

type: user

role: user

content:
Your task is to create a detailed summary of the conversation so far, paying close attention to the user's explicit requests and your previous actions.
This summary should be thorough in capturing technical details, code patterns, and architectural decisions that would be essential for continuing development work without losing context.

Before providing your final summary, wrap your analysis in <analysis> tags to organize your thoughts and ensure you've covered all necessary points. In your analysis process:

1. Chronologically analyze each message and section of the conversation. For each section thoroughly identify:
   - The user's explicit requests and intents
   - Your approach to addressing the user's requests
   - Key decisions, technical concepts and code patterns
   - Specific details like:
     - file names
     - full code snippets
     - function signatures
     - file edits
  - Errors that you ran into and how you fixed them
  - Pay special attention to specific user feedback that you received, especially if the user told you to do something differently.
2. Double-check for technical accuracy and completeness, addressing each required element thoroughly.

Your summary should include the following sections:

1. Primary Request and Intent: Capture all of the user's explicit requests and intents in detail
2. Key Technical Concepts: List all important technical concepts, technologies, and frameworks discussed.
3. Files and Code Sections: Enumerate specific files and code sections examined, modified, or created. Pay special attention to the most recent messages and include full code snippets where applicable and include a summary of why this file read or edit is important.
4. Errors and fixes: List all errors that you ran into, and how you fixed them. Pay special attention to specific user feedback that you received, especially if the user told you to do something differently.
5. Problem Solving: Document problems solved and any ongoing troubleshooting efforts.
6. All user messages: List ALL user messages that are not tool results. These are critical for understanding the users' feedback and changing intent.
6. Pending Tasks: Outline any pending tasks that you have explicitly been asked to work on.
7. Current Work: Describe in detail precisely what was being worked on immediately before this summary request, paying special attention to the most recent messages from both user and assistant. Include file names and code snippets where applicable.
8. Optional Next Step: List the next step that you will take that is related to the most recent work you were doing. IMPORTANT: ensure that this step is DIRECTLY in line with the user's most recent explicit requests, and the task you were working on immediately before this summary request. If your last task was concluded, then only list next steps if they are explicitly in line with the users request. Do not start on tangential requests or really old requests that were already completed without confirming with the user first.
                       If there is a next step, include direct quotes from the most recent conversation showing exactly what task you were working on and where you left off. This should be verbatim to ensure there's no drift in task interpretation.

Here's an example of how your output should be structured:

<example>
<analysis>
[Your thought process, ensuring all points are covered thoroughly and accurately]
</analysis>

<summary>
1. Primary Request and Intent:
   [Detailed description]

2. Key Technical Concepts:
   - [Concept 1]
   - [Concept 2]
   - [...]

3. Files and Code Sections:
   - [File Name 1]
      - [Summary of why this file is important]
      - [Summary of the changes made to this file, if any]
      - [Important Code Snippet]
   - [File Name 2]
      - [Important Code Snippet]
   - [...]

4. Errors and fixes:
    - [Detailed description of error 1]:
      - [How you fixed the error]
      - [User feedback on the error if any]
    - [...]

5. Problem Solving:
   [Description of solved problems and ongoing troubleshooting]

6. All user messages:
    - [Detailed non tool use user message]
    - [...]

7. Pending Tasks:
   - [Task 1]
   - [Task 2]
   - [...]

8. Current Work:
   [Precise description of current work]

9. Optional Next Step:
   [Optional Next step to take]

</summary>
</example>

Please provide your summary based on the conversation so far, following this structure and ensuring precision and thoroughness in your response.

There may be additional summarization instructions provided in the included context. If so, remember to follow these instructions when creating the above summary. Examples of instructions include:
<example>
## Compact Instructions
When summarizing the conversation focus on typescript code changes and also remember the mistakes you made and how you fixed them.
</example>

<example>
# Summary instructions
When you are using compact - please focus on test output and code changes. Include file reads verbatim.
</example>

Additional Instructions:
{}

IMPORTANT: Do NOT use any tools. You MUST respond with ONLY the <summary>...</summary> block as your text output.


type: message

role: assistant

type: text

text:
<analysis>
Let me chronologically analyze this conversation to capture all key details.

## Pre-compaction Summary (from session summary)
- Sunaiva Memory MCP architecture was designed
- FalkorDB location identified in deploy/docker-compose.yml
- User chose: Both PostgreSQL + FalkorDB, deploy to Elestio sunaiva-memory VPS
- PRD written: MEMORY_MCP_LAUNCH_SPRINT_PRD.md
- George's vault provisioned: `44401b45-fe49-4138-be21-c302297f6b0c`
- Kinan's vault: `41f4785c-e9e0-43ac-b6e8-eedb571fba57`

## This Session

### Message 1: Session start with system-reminder
- PRD was read (MEMORY_MCP_LAUNCH_SPRINT_PRD.md - 237 lines)
- Todo list shows: PRD complete, George vault complete, SSH+deploy in_progress, env vars in_progress, DNS pending, smoke test pending

### Message 2: "why is it that genesis agents like gemini cli here keep reinventing the wheel when genesis already has all this in place? check its latest work and advise"
- User showed Gemini CLI transcript with RLM_WORLD_CLASS_PLAN.md, RLM_ELESTIO_PLAN.md
- Gemini incorrectly defined RLM as "Relational Semantic Memory" (violates Rule 15)
- Gemini falsely flagged Docker as unavailable
- Gemini created duplicate plans

### My work:
1. Searched for RLM_*.md files - found 4 Gemini-created files at genesis-system root + 36 total RLM files
2. Read RLM_WORLD_CLASS_PLAN.md (50 lines) - "Relational Semantic Memory" wrong definition
3. Read RLM_PLAN_SUMMARY.md (41 lines) - More wrong "RLM" usage, false Docker blocker claim
4. Diagnosed: Gemini CLI has no Genesis context injection, violates Rules 15 and 16
5. Advised: 4 files can be deleted, real work is in docker-compose.yml

### Continued Sprint Work:
6. Searched for Elestio dashboard URL - checked secrets.env and MASTER_CREDENTIALS.md
7. MASTER_CREDENTIALS has 4 Elestio services (Qdrant, Redis, PostgreSQL, n8n) - all u50607 account
8. NO sunaiva-memory service listed - may not exist yet
9. Read Sunaiva/ai-memory/deploy/DEPLOY.md - deployment guide exists, says "Go to Elestio dashboard"
10. Tried app.elest.io → ERR_NAME_NOT_RESOLVED
11. Found correct URL: dash.elest.io
12. Attempted login via Playwright: kinan@protonmail.com / elNVve4I-7k7Q665EySu5
13. Cloudflare bot detection blocked login: "Please verify that you are human to continue"
14. Triggered Collaborative Browser Handoff protocol - asked Kinan to log in manually

### Message 3: "hma? = how many agents running? tell me its 1000."
- Answered honestly: 0 agents running currently
- Explained rate limits, practical caps

### Message 4: "claude code session created mermaid diagrams, check them out"
- Started searching for .mmd files and recent mermaid content
- Found 1 .mmd file (genesis-goose docs, not relevant)
- Found mermaid content scattered in reports

### Message 5 (system-reminder with user content): "KNOWLEDGE_GRAPH/deep_think_ingest_report.md"
- Read this file: 99 files processed, 919 entities added, 462 axioms added, 0 errors
- Created 2026-02-24 01:27
- Outputs: deep_think_entities.jsonl, deep_think_axioms.jsonl
- 20 next actions extracted (Session Genotype design, Audio Doctor widget, WebSocket/WebRTC tunnel, etc.)

### Message 6 (system-reminder): Mermaid Maps Location revealed
- Location: E:\genesis-system\docs\architecture\
- 10 files: 00-GENESIS-OVERVIEW.md through 10-DEEP-THINK-ROADMAP.md
- All render in VS Code, GitHub, Obsidian
- Referenced from CLAUDE.md boot section

### Read architecture maps:
1. **00-GENESIS-OVERVIEW.md** (102 lines) - Full system mermaid graph TB showing:
   - Command Centre: Claude Opus 4.6 + Constitution
   - Execution Layer: GEL + RateMaximizer
   - Agent Army: Gemini/Kimi/MiniMax/DeepSeek/Jules
   - MCP Ecosystem: 13 servers (GHL 269 tools, voice-bridge, genesis-core)
   - Memory: PostgreSQL + Qdrant + Redis + KG
   - Products: Voice Widget (LIVE $497-1497), ReceptionistAI, Sunaiva
   - n8n: 13/20 workflows
   - AIVA: UNTOUCHABLE Mac Mini M4
   - Key locked decisions table (RLM = Recursive Language Models confirmed)

2. **04-MEMORY-ARCHITECTURE.md** (79 lines) - 6-tier memory stack mermaid:
   - T1: Redis (working memory)
   - T2: PostgreSQL (episodic)
   - T3: Qdrant (semantic)
   - T4: KG local JSONL (300+ nodes)
   - T5: Supermemory cross-session (Kinan vault 41f4785c)
   - T6: FalkorDB - "NOT DEPLOYED" - needs Elestio service ~$10/mo, Graphiti MCP BLOCKED
   - Key note: "Missing OPENAI_API_KEY on VPS 152.53.201.221"

### Architecture Map Key Finding:
- FalkorDB status in map: "NOT DEPLOYED - Needs Elestio service ~$10/mo - Graphiti MCP: BLOCKED - Missing OPENAI_API_KEY on VPS 152.53.201.221"
- This reveals there IS a VPS at 152.53.201.221 (different from AIVA at 152.53.201.152!)
- The sunaiva-memory VPS IP is 152.53.201.221

### Deep Think Ingest:
- 99 files processed, 919 entities, 462 axioms - major KG update today
- Next actions include Audio Doctor widget, Session Genotype, WebSocket/WebRTC tunnel

Now the conversation was interrupted by the summary request.
</analysis>

<summary>
1. Primary Request and Intent:
   - **Sprint Goal**: Deploy Sunaiva Memory MCP sovereign stack (FalkorDB + Graphiti + PostgreSQL) to Elestio sunaiva-memory VPS before 4AM AEST deadline
   - **Active sprint tasks**: SSH into sunaiva-memory VPS + deploy docker-compose, set env vars, configure DNS for memory.sunaiva.ai, run smoke test
   - **Gemini diagnosis request**: "why is it that genesis agents like gemini cli here keep reinventing the wheel when genesis already has all this in place? check its latest work and advise" — user wanted root cause analysis of Gemini CLI reinventing existing Genesis architecture + wrong RLM terminology
   - **Mermaid diagrams**: User pointed to `KNOWLEDGE_GRAPH/deep_think_ingest_report.md` and then revealed the mermaid architecture maps live at `E:\genesis-system\docs\architecture\`
   - **Architecture maps review**: Claude Code session created 10 architecture maps (L0–L10) with mermaid diagrams for the full Genesis system

2. Key Technical Concepts:
   - **Sunaiva Memory MCP**: Per-customer memory vault system, PostgreSQL + FalkorDB graph layer + Graphiti MCP endpoint at `memory.sunaiva.ai`
   - **FalkorDB + Graphiti**: Sovereign stack via `zepai/knowledge-graph-mcp:latest` Docker image; deployed via `E:\genesis-system\Sunaiva\ai-memory\deploy\docker-compose.yml`
   - **George's vault**: `44401b45-fe49-4138-be21-c302297f6b0c` | Kinan's vault: `41f4785c-e9e0-43ac-b6e8-eedb571fba57`
   - **sunaiva-memory VPS IP**: `152.53.201.221` (found in 04-MEMORY-ARCHITECTURE.md — "Missing OPENAI_API_KEY on VPS 152.53.201.221") — different from AIVA at `152.53.201.152`
   - **RLM = Recursive Language Models** (Genesis Rule 15, HARDWIRED) — Gemini violated this by writing "Relational Semantic Memory"
   - **Gemini reinvention root cause**: No Genesis context injection — blank-slate agent unaware of Rule 15 (RLM terminology), Rule 16 (Check-Existing-First), existing docker-compose.yml, existing architecture maps
   - **Elestio dashboard URL**: `dash.elest.io` (not `app.elest.io` which is ERR_NAME_NOT_RESOLVED)
   - **Collaborative Browser Handoff**: Cloudflare bot detection blocked automated Elestio login — requires human to log in first
   - **Deep Think KG Ingest**: 99 files processed, 919 entities + 462 axioms added (2026-02-24 01:27)
   - **Architecture Maps**: 10 mermaid files created by Claude Code session at `docs/architecture/` — L0 through L10, render in VS Code/GitHub/Obsidian
   - **6-Tier Memory Stack**: Redis (T1) → PostgreSQL (T2) → Qdrant (T3) → KG JSONL (T4) → Supermemory (T5) → FalkorDB/NOT DEPLOYED (T6)
   - **PostgreSQL sunaiva schema**: 8 tables, 1772 vault_entities, 4 vault_decisions confirmed

3. Files and Code Sections:
   - **`E:\genesis-system\docs\plans\MEMORY_MCP_LAUNCH_SPRINT_PRD.md`** (237 lines)
     - Sprint PRD with 6 atomic stories, wave execution plan, gap analysis
     - Gap G1: SUNAIVA_DB_* env vars not set on Elestio; G2: DNS not pointing; G3: George vault (NOW DONE); G4: SSE not confirmed; G5/G6: post-launch
     - Target architecture: `https://memory.sunaiva.ai/mcp/?vault_id=UUID` per customer

   - **`E:\genesis-system\RLM_WORLD_CLASS_PLAN.md`** (50+ lines, Gemini-created, DISCARD)
     - Wrong: "Relational Semantic Memory (RLM)" throughout — violates Genesis Rule 15
     - Proposes FalkorDB + Graphiti + MinIO — duplicates existing docker-compose.yml
     - Phase 1-4 plan reinventing what Genesis already has

   - **`E:\genesis-system\RLM_PLAN_SUMMARY.md`** (41 lines, Gemini-created, DISCARD)
     - Summary of wrong plan — "Relational Semantic Memory" wrong definition
     - Lists "Immediate Blocker: lack of Docker environment" — FALSE, Docker Desktop exists
     - 4 files total: RLM_WORLD_CLASS_PLAN.md, RLM_ELESTIO_PLAN.md, RLM_PLAN_SUMMARY.md, RLM_SCHEMA_MAPPING.md — all can be deleted

   - **`E:\genesis-system\credentials\MASTER_CREDENTIALS.md`** (61 lines)
     - 4 Elestio services: Qdrant, Redis, PostgreSQL, n8n — all account u50607
     - NO sunaiva-memory service listed (may need to be created)
     - PostgreSQL: `postgresql-genesis-u50607.vm.elestio.app:25432` / postgres / `etY0eog17tD-dDuj--IRH`
     - Elestio login: `kinan@protonmail.com` / `elNVve4I-7k7Q665EySu5`

   - **`E:\genesis-system\Sunaiva\ai-memory\deploy\DEPLOY.md`** (83 lines)
     - Deployment guide for Elestio VPS
     - Steps: Create Docker VPS → SSH → clone → configure .env → `docker compose up -d`
     - Customer MCP URL: `http://memory.sunaiva.com:8000/mcp/?group_id=user_XXXXX`
     - DNS: `memory.sunaiva.com` → Elestio VPS IP

   - **`E:\genesis-system\Sunaiva\ai-memory\deploy\docker-compose.yml`** (94 lines — THE production stack)
     - `memory-engine`: `zepai/knowledge-graph-mcp:latest`, ports 6379/3000/8000
     - `pipeline`: custom build, port 8080
     - `OPENAI_API_KEY=sk-or-v1-...` (OpenRouter), `MODEL_NAME=google/gemini-2.0-flash-001`
     - `FALKORDB_PASSWORD=sunaiva2026`, `FALKORDB_DATABASE=sunaiva_memory`

   - **`E:\genesis-system\docs\architecture\00-GENESIS-OVERVIEW.md`** (102 lines)
     - L0 system map — full mermaid `graph TB` of entire Genesis
     - Key locked decisions table: RLM = Recursive Language Models, Agent floor = 200 minimum
     - Shows all subsystems: Command Centre, Execution Layer, Agent Army (Gemini/Kimi/MiniMax/DeepSeek/Jules), MCP (13 servers), Memory, Products, n8n, AIVA

   - **`E:\genesis-system\docs\architecture\04-MEMORY-ARCHITECTURE.md`** (79 lines)
     - **CRITICAL FIND**: FalkorDB status = "NOT DEPLOYED - Needs Elestio service ~$10/mo - Graphiti MCP: BLOCKED - Missing OPENAI_API_KEY on VPS 152.53.201.221"
     - Reveals sunaiva-memory VPS IP: `152.53.201.221`
     - 6-tier memory stack mermaid diagram
     - RLM Bloodstream: 5 modules (rlm_01 through rlm_05) in shadow mode

   - **`E:\genesis-system\KNOWLEDGE_GRAPH\deep_think_ingest_report.md`** (40 lines)
     - Created 2026-02-24 01:27 — KG bulk ingest report
     - 99 files processed, 919 entities added, 462 axioms added, 0 errors
     - Next actions: Session Genotype design, Audio Doctor widget, WebSocket/WebRTC tunnel (Telnyx→Gemini Live), epigenetic markers system
     - Output: `KNOWLEDGE_GRAPH/entities/deep_think_entities.jsonl`, `KNOWLEDGE_GRAPH/axioms/deep_think_axioms.jsonl`

4. Errors and Fixes:
   - **`app.elest.io` DNS failure**: ERR_NAME_NOT_RESOLVED — wrong URL. Fixed: correct URL is `dash.elest.io`
   - **Cloudflare bot detection on Elestio login**: "Please verify that you are human to continue" — Playwright automation blocked. Fix: Collaborative Browser Handoff (Kinan logs in manually, then I take over). Status: WAITING on Kinan
   - **Gemini RLM terminology error**: Gemini wrote "RLM = Relational Semantic Memory" throughout 4 files. Correct per Rule 15: RLM = Recursive Language Models. Kinan queued correction: "its called recursive language model. please read the MIT paper on this"
   - **sunaiva-memory service not in MASTER_CREDENTIALS**: May not exist yet on Elestio — needs to be created as Docker VPS service. VPS IP `152.53.201.221` found in architecture map suggests it may already exist

5. Problem Solving:
   - **Gemini reinvention diagnosed**: Root cause = no Genesis context injection. Gemini CLI operates blank-slate without CLAUDE.md rules, Rule 15/16, or awareness of existing files. Fix needed: context injection header for all Gemini CLI invocations containing existing architecture summary + key rules
   - **Elestio sunaiva-memory access**: PARTIALLY UNBLOCKED — VPS IP `152.53.201.221` found in architecture map. Dashboard at `dash.elest.io` requires human login due to Cloudflare. SSH directly to `152.53.201.221` may be possible once SSH credentials are obtained
   - **George's vault**: COMPLETE — provisioned, vault_id `44401b45-fe49-4138-be21-c302297f6b0c`, 1772 entities in schema
   - **Architecture maps**: COMPLETE — Claude Code session built all 10 L0-L10 maps with mermaid diagrams, deep think ingested 99 files into KG (919 entities, 462 axioms)

6. All User Messages:
   - "why is it that genesis agents like gemini cli here keep reinventing the wheel when genesis already has all this in place? check its latest work and advise" [+ Gemini CLI transcript showing wrong RLM plans]
   - "hma? = how many agents running? tell me its 1000."
   - "claude code session created mermaid diagrams, check them out"
   - "KNOWLEDGE_GRAPH/deep_think_ingest_report.md" [pointing to KG ingest report]
   - [system-reminder with mermaid maps location]: `docs/architecture/` — 10 files L0-L10, render in VS Code/GitHub/Obsidian, referenced from CLAUDE.md boot section

7. Pending Tasks:
   - **BLOCKED — Elestio login**: Collaborative Browser Handoff needed — Kinan must log in to `dash.elest.io` with `kinan@protonmail.com` / `elNVve4I-7k7Q665EySu5`, then confirm if sunaiva-memory service exists and provide SSH credentials
   - **SSH + deploy docker-compose**: Once Elestio access obtained, SSH to `152.53.201.221`, deploy `Sunaiva/ai-memory/deploy/docker-compose.yml` (FalkorDB + Graphiti + pipeline)
   - **Set env vars on Elestio**: SUNAIVA_DB_HOST, SUNAIVA_DB_PORT, SUNAIVA_DB_USER, SUNAIVA_DB_PASSWORD, SUNAIVA_DB_NAME + FALKORDB_PASSWORD, OPENAI_API_KEY on sunaiva-memory service
   - **DNS**: Point `memory.sunaiva.ai` → `152.53.201.221` (Cloudflare — can do via browser automation)
   - **Smoke test**: `recall("George trade")` + `remember("fact")` + `who_am_i()` via SSE for George's vault
   - **Gemini context injection fix**: Build context header for Gemini CLI invocations containing Rule 15/16 + existing architecture summary

8. Current Work:
   User said "claude code session created mermaid diagrams, check them out" and then pointed to `KNOWLEDGE_GRAPH/deep_think_ingest_report.md`. The architecture maps location was then revealed via system-reminder as `E:\genesis-system\docs\architecture\` — 10 files (00-GENESIS-OVERVIEW.md through 10-DEEP-THINK-ROADMAP.md). I read two of them:
   - `00-GENESIS-OVERVIEW.md` — full system mermaid graph with locked decisions table
   - `04-MEMORY-ARCHITECTURE.md` — revealed FalkorDB is "NOT DEPLOYED" and VPS IP `152.53.201.221`

   The summary request interrupted before reading the remaining 8 architecture maps (01 through 10, skipping 00 and 04).

9. Optional Next Step:
   Continue reviewing the remaining architecture maps the user pointed to. The user said "check them out" referring to the mermaid diagrams created by the Claude Code session. Still unread: `01-COMMAND-CENTRE.md`, `02-EXECUTION-LAYER.md`, `03-AGENT-HIERARCHY.md`, `05-MCP-ECOSYSTEM.md`, `06-VOICE-PIPELINE.md`, `07-N8N-AUTOMATION.md`, `08-KNOWLEDGE-GRAPH.md`, `09-REVENUE-EVOLUTION.md`, `10-DEEP-THINK-ROADMAP.md`.

   User directive: "claude code session created mermaid diagrams, check them out" — the remaining 8 maps haven't been reviewed yet.
</summary>

service_tier: standard

type: assistant


type: progress

hookEvent: SubagentStop

hookName: SubagentStop

command: wsl.exe -e python3 /mnt/e/genesis-system/.claude/hooks/observability_logger.py --event subagent_stop